MAC Cosmetics Brushstroke Eyeliner Fades in Hours – Not Long-Lasting as Claimed

I’ve previously used MAC Cosmetics’ Liquidlast 24-Hour Eyeliner, and it stayed on perfectly, even when I went swimming. However, when I tried the Brushstroke 24-Hour Eyeliner, I was extremely disappointed. Within just a few hours, the color fades, smudges, and transfers onto my eyelids. The product’s longevity is terrible and does not live up to the 24-hour wear claim. If it can’t deliver what it promises, why advertise it as long-lasting? I feel like this eyeliner doesn’t justify the price at all. I’m very dissatisfied and expect MAC to either improve the formula or stop misleading customers with false claims.